Twitter | Search | |
T. Greg Doucette
In today's criminal justice news, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals holds police officers can *steal $100K+ of someone's property* and still be protected by qualified immunity to avoid any accountability Because it's "not clearly established" that cops stealing is illegal
Reply Retweet Like More
T. Greg Doucette Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
Remember that protecting wholesale lawlessness by police is a feature – not a bug – of qualified immunity Here are some more examples from an earlier thread:
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
Keep all these cases in mind when police, like that Kuebler fellow, try to tell you Qualified Immunity is just there to protect hardworking cops from those meanie lawyers
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
I mean you'd *think* that would be the case, right? But no, this decision holds that stealing isn't illegal when done by the police – as long as these particular officers were the first to do it That's how qualified immunity works in practice 😕
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
Yep Because this case only held it was illegal to steal rare coins and cash. The Court of Appeals hasn't considered whether it's illegal to steal your car
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
That's correct: it was the result of the Supreme Court's ruling in Pearson v Callahan back in 2009 The serialized two-prong approach they had previously required was replaced with an either-prong analysis. So lower courts took shortest paths to dismissal
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
I agree. But the problem is that it's totally in line with how all the other Circuits decide these cases too, which in turn is based on repeated SCOTUS opinions – and per curiam orders, and denials of cert – chipping away at §1983 cases
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 21
Replying to @greg_doucette
Theft is "reasonable," says "professional police officer"
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 21
Replying to @greg_doucette
Wait, are y... are you suggesting a man with "professional police officer" in his bio is deliberately misinforming people about the law?? 😱
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 21
Replying to @greg_doucette
"No taxation without representation. Unless it's by a Government employee stealing your stuff." doesn't have the same ring to it
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 21
Replying to @greg_doucette
Oh, you must have missed him on the other thread then 😂
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 21
Replying to @greg_doucette
Morals are for cucks
Reply Retweet Like
T. Greg Doucette Mar 21
Replying to @greg_doucette
I said it back during the campaign when H972 passed: the love of police brutality is strongly bipartisan
Reply Retweet Like
Corn Pop 🔪🌽 Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
Also remember this when people say the Ninth Circuit is some sort of progressive rebel compared to the other Courts. Same outcomes. Just the names, faces, and jurisdictions change.
Reply Retweet Like
Clark Neily Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
I mean, when you put it that way...
Reply Retweet Like
George Stocker Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
The boston tea party started for less.
Reply Retweet Like
Scott Greenfield Mar 21
Replying to @greg_doucette
Those 9th Circuit badgelickers strike again. Oh wait.
Reply Retweet Like
Stephan Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette @mey621
Reply Retweet Like
John Druva Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
This is a Ninth Circuit decision that cries out to be overruled
Reply Retweet Like
Eric M. Mullins Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
So, let me see if I have this right. Stealing is not stealing. Illegal is not illegal. Police are the thieves. The money is the crime. Money is also a person, but police are not? Ghuoliani was right. Truth is not truth.
Reply Retweet Like
Eric M. Mullins Mar 20
Replying to @greg_doucette
Also, damning evidence supporting the phrase kangaroo courts.
Reply Retweet Like