Twitter | Pretraživanje | |
Chris Chambers
Imagine being the famous professor at a prestigious institution who feels comfortable writing this👇 in a manuscript review of an ECR's preregistered (non-RR) study This is one of the reasons I believe professors should have to sign their reviews
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se" More
Chris Crandall 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @chrisdc77
An example of what happens when one leaves the Twitter echo-verse. One needn’t clutch one’s pearls—this author’s views are not uncommon. You may think her/him wrong. Grapple directly with them.
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Bobbie Spellman 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @chrisdc77
Why did the editor forward that review to the authors? Yeah I know we can get into a debate about whether editors should EDIT reviews. But this review is useless to the authors and just a scolding to the editor re: what is appropriate for consideration in the journal.
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Chris Chambers 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @BobbiePoPS
That is the Q. IME, revs like this sometimes also contain useful content, & since I don't like to edit reviews (for me it's all in or binned), it leaves the ed in a tricky situation. Had I edited this one, I'd have left it in but told authors they need not respond to this comment
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Chris Chambers 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @chrisdc77
Happy ending though -- the authors responded with admirable patience to this nonsense & the manuscript was accepted
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Andrew Althouse 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @chrisdc77
I HAVE A DEGREE IN THIS FIELD!
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Chris Chambers 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @ADAlthousePhD
I HAVE A HORSE
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Liuba Papeo 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @chrisdc77
I don’t understand this public shaming of a comment written with kindness and that has some truth. 🙆‍♀️
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Chris Chambers 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @ljuba_pi
Haha 🙃 But of course the reason I shared it in the 1st place was out of admiration and gratitude, and so we might all learn something And the ONLY reason I think the professor should have signed this review was to claim rightful credit for such a wise and generous contribution
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Reubs J Walsh 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @chrisdc77
And yet I’m not sure it’s an argument entirely without merit. Just an utterly absurd context in which to raise it.
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"
Chris Chambers 31. sij
Odgovor korisniku/ci @reubsjw
Yeah there are elements I could agree with. For example, I think there is strand of this comment that is basically saying "we aren't hypothesis testing in this field, so there is little or no point preregistering" & w/ certain caveats that IMO is defensible & maybe even sensible
Reply Retweet Označi sa "sviđa mi se"