Twitter | Search | |
Ahad
How difficult is it for you to do your research when a few times there are multiple versions of one incident? For example..
Reply Retweet Like More
Ahad Feb 11
Replying to @iandavidmorris
the incident of Umar coming to Ali/Fatima's house to make Ali pledge allegiance to Abu Bakr's caliphate. Some sources...
Reply Retweet Like
Ahad Feb 11
Replying to @iandavidmorris
(Mostly Shia) say Umar broke the door down and caused Fatima's miscarriage. Some sources (Sunni) say the incident...
Reply Retweet Like
Ahad Feb 12
Replying to @iandavidmorris
never happened! How do you get to the get that right? I've found that to be troubling when reading Islamic history.
Reply Retweet Like
Ian D. Morris Feb 13
Replying to @ahadrx7
Yeah, contradictions are endemic. It may be useful to ask what are the underlying, unspoken assumptions in a report. From my notes:
Reply Retweet Like
Ian D. Morris Feb 13
Replying to @ahadrx7
But even that is no guarantee, because seemingly innocuous facts can be shown to be inventions that later went mainstream.
Reply Retweet Like
Ian D. Morris Feb 13
Replying to @ahadrx7
I don’t think we can actually “get it right”: we learn more from critiquing and problematising than hyperselective storytelling.
Reply Retweet Like